Okay, maybe the title of this blog post is a little over the top - but I could not come up with something more creative.
In the German community, there was a lot of heated discussion about a change in forum rules & moderation guidelines we did for the BBV forum in early May.
Before I start looking into the numbers, first some basic information:
What's the BBV?
BBV stands for "Beats, Brags & Variances" and was originally intended and used as a kind of fun forum for things happening in your poker life and sometimes outside of it. Over the years, it developed to become something very special to our biggest community: the humoristic gravity centre of PokerStrategy.com, even creating it's own memes.
To the right, you can see one piece of creative output, featuring Fenris photoshopped in a poster of the movie "Downfall" along with a dozen minor details that is a great illustration on said change management and the conflict it created.
To see more of the movie posters with community celebrities like Korn photoshopped in them, click here.
Why the Rule Changes?
We had the feeling that even though the BBV forum was great fun, the old rule of even flames being kind of legal inside of it's boundaries had negative effects on the whole mood in the forums. Even though it cannot be proven, we also counted a lot of the aggressive tone especially towards beginners in the forums on that issue.
Thus, we changed the rules to ban flames / insults and intense spam from the BBV. As it was to expect, this change resulted in some kind of a rebellion amongst the BBV forum regulars who felt - understandably - like one of their freedoms was taken away from them.
Even though the two side of the argument did neither win nor lose the opinion war, at least the daily life situation nowadays is kind of okay. Maybe a kind of a cold war between the hardcore BBV regulars and 'us' (i.e. admins / mods).
Effect of the Rule Changes
Our theory was that even though banning flames might lead to the loss of a certain aspect of the chaotic humour created in the BBV, it will ultimately lead to even more of the real fun stuff that does not relate to insults/flaming directly. The ratio behind this theory is that the 'old' BBV also kept a lot of intelligent, humorous people out of the BBV as they did not want to be insulted/flamed etc.
I accept anyone who has a different opinion on that matter - people and their tastes are different, of course. Still, I was curious on the numbers: as quality of the posts / humour is hard to measure, could we at least measure the quantitative aspect? And wouldn't someone who really likes the 'new' BBV come more often and vice versa?
Well, here's the page views on the forum overview of the BBV on a monthly basis:
Month - Page Views - % of total
January - 348.445 - 2.09%
February - 375.639 - 2.26%
March - 391.956 - 2.19%
April - 458.423 - 2,85%
Mai - 609.711 - 3,77%
Juni - 563.400 - 3,37%
Even though this proves nothing really, it is a relief for me. The growth in May was of course due to the big discussions going on over the change management (May 11 was the day of days), but the positive numbers in June make me feel that the BBV still thrives.
"Downfall" poster by schmeiss, "Lord of the Kings" poster by MrTef1on